Dropping the Mask
I’ve been pondering the concept of authenticity a lot lately.
A couple of years ago my church started a project to clarify its vision and mission. That lengthy (and sometimes painful) process produced a series of core values that define why we do the things we do. The most intriguing for me has been the core value of “Unexpected Authenticity.”
I’ve been turning this over and around in my mind for quite a while, attempting to come to grips with what it means for me and how to live it out. It’s a tough concept and I haven’t really wanted to embrace it. I guess it’s natural to leap to the conclusion that being authentic just means being more honest. But to me, it’s more about being true to myself in all aspects of my existence and acting in a way that’s consistent with my core beliefs, values, feelings, and identity.
When I recently decided to get serious about writing and made the commitment to blog, I needed a name for my virtual plot of land on the Web. I eventually landed on “Authentic Ramblings.” If you’ve read any of my stuff, you no doubt get the “rambling” aspect, but I want to unpack the “authentic” part a little more.
I’ve lived much of my life pinned beneath the weight of towering expectations. Some are imposed by others, some are imagined “stories” I create in my head about what I think others expect of me, but most are prisons of despair I create and impose on myself. Deep down inside I recognize there’s a discontinuity between my own expectations of who I should be, and the reality of who I know I really am. This tension in my soul fuels the feelings of despair. When I’m really honest with myself, I know I don’t have it all together and I can’t be the man that I pressure myself to be. The expectations are just too high.
This scenario kicks me into a very unhealthy cycle. There’s a natural friction between my desire to conform and avoid the disapproval and criticism of others, and the internal recognition that I really can’t meet all the demands placed on me. I seek to reconcile these emotions by pretending to be someone I’m really not. I become a counterfeit, an actor wearing a mask, someone very different from the man God created me to be. And I hate myself for it.
This cycle of pretending isn’t always obvious or overt and it’s usually manifested in little betrayals. I might remain silent during controversial conversations even when I have strong conflicting opinions. I may pretend to be a fan of World Cup Soccer by nodding and mumbling an enthusiastic “mmm hmmm!” even though I’m not really interested and don’t follow the sport. These examples may seem minor when viewed individually, but it’s the consistent pattern of “image maintenance” that becomes dangerous.
Overwhelming anxiety, fear, and self-consciousness overtake me when I’m not living authentically and resting in my true identity. Ultimately, I know this fear is rooted in a lack of faith and an unwillingness to believe that who I am in Christ Jesus is enough. Living authentically is essential for my spiritual health.
Is true authenticity easy? It’s not for me, and this has been an extremely difficult post to write. I’ve agonized for days over how much to say, what to reveal, how far to put myself out there. Living authentically feels risky. When I drop the mask, I’m compelled to expose my weaknesses, insecurities, and disappointments. I open myself up to criticism and feelings of disapproval. Experience is showing me, however, that the rewards far outweigh the risks. It’s freedom.
Writing about my thoughts and experiences in this blog is a cathartic method for processing my journey to authenticity. My use of self-deprecating humor in the approach is a continual reminder to me not to take myself so seriously, which in turn helps me to live more comfortably in my own skin.
I’m definitely on a life-long journey. It’s not a twitch-your-nose and “poof” you’re there kind of deal (yes, I’m a child of the 70’s). When I consistently put into practice what God is teaching me, I build up the necessary muscle memory to continue my growth. I’m working hard to keep my foundation anchored and rooted in what God says about me and the sufficiency of His grace, not the “image” that I’ve created in my head. Specifically, God’s word says that I am:
-
His child (John 1:12, Romans 8:16)
-
Christ’s friend (John 15:15)
-
Loved by Him (John 16:27)
-
Specifically chosen by Him (John 15:16)
-
Forever free from condemnation (Romans 8:1)
-
Free from sin’s power over me (Romans 6:7)
-
Accepted! (Romans 15:7)
Let me hear from you! What does authenticity mean to you? What are your challenges with living authentically?


Oh how I wish I didn’t know exactly how you feel Jon. I’m convinced everybody around me is perfect because they look perfect on the outside. Nothing could be further from the truth though. Everybody has insecurities, doubts and things they don’t like about themselves. Many people have very serious issues they cover up to save face. I’m personally humbled and very impressed with your honesty and candor. EXCELLENT POST JON!!!
Thank you so much, Jeff.
Wow Jon,
This is incredible. I can totally relate!!
Thanks Barry.
Wow, Jon, this is something that everyone can connect with. Thank you for putting words to the thoughts and feelings and sharing them on your blog.
I love your banner picture, too. Where was it taken? It looks like the caribbean, just beautiful and brings a smile to my face!
Thanks Denise! How are you doing?
The pic is actually from Bermuda, last month.
[...] accomplish within me so that I can be truly authentic? I defined the term for myself in one of my earlier posts last year: “Being true to myself in all aspects of my existence and acting in a way that’s [...]
Jon,
Excellent post. The word “authentic” came alive to me in 2008 when I made a healing weekend. On this weekend I learned that I hadn’t been authentic with myself or others. Part of being authentic for me is allowing myself to feel emotions, and I didn’t know that this was a problem for me until I attended that weekend. Since then, “authenticity” has become something I try to strive towards. I can relate so much to your writing on this. It’s a struggle and very difficult to live an “authentic” life. I too, find myself making little sounds or comments to show I may be interested in certain sports when I am not. It’s almost like I need to always be aware of my goal of living in authenticity and when I’m not, I naturally go the other way.
I struggled even in writing this little response. But the rewards of living authentically and sharing with others from the heart is amazing. I feel alive and actually live my life rather than go through it numbly. Like you, Christ is my life. It is Christ who gives me the Graces to live in authenticity and to continue to grow as a man in this regard on a daily basis. Thanks Jon for your authentic words. God bless you.
David – thanks for sharing, I appreciate your comments and insight!
Jon,
Thank you for taking the time and effort to share your thoughts and for the invitation to us to follow your “ramblings” and reflect upon what you have written. You write well and speak to such a significant issue that all of us struggle with….how to be truly authentic. To me being authentic is being consistent with who I am, as a man who is created in the image of God. Jesus is also for me the well-spring of life. Yet I struggle with the “shoulds” and the “should nots”of living a religious life rather than an authentic, spiritually centered life. It is currently something that I am struggling with at a very deep personal level. I find very few with whom I can process these deeper issues in full openness, honesty and transparency. Thank you for sharing your “ramblings” as they touch a deep core within me. I look forward to continuing to follow your posts. Thanks again for sharing and inviting us to follow and share our thoughts as well!
John
Thanks John. My goal is to be as authentic interpersonally as I am in writing. Not quite there yet, but making progress! I appreciate you reading my stuff.